Showing posts with label Adapter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adapter. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 August 2013

Wi-Fi adapter shootout: Qualcomm versus Intel in an 802.11 battle

Gamers are always hunting for a competitive edge, and the folks at Bigfoot Networks—now a part of Qualcomm Atheros—have long promised to deliver network interface cards that perform better with online games and other latency-sensitive applications. To demonstrate its prowess in this area, the company sent me two identical Alienware notebooks, one equipped with Qualcomm’s Killer Wireless-N 1202 and the other with Intel’s Centrino Advanced-N 6230.

Robert CardinWe benchmarked two otherwise identical Alienware laptops: one outfitted with a Killer Wireless-N 1202 NIC (left) and the other with Intel's Centrino Advanced-N 6230 (right).

Both NICs are dual-band adapters that can connect to an 802.11n router on either the 2.4GHz or 5GHz frequency band. Both also support two spatial streams for a maximum physical link rate of 300 megabits per second. Some gaming-laptop manufacturers, including Alienware, offer Killer NICs as standard equipment, while others offer the adapters as added-cost upgrades. You can also purchase one of these cards by itself and upgrade your existing notebook, provided that the system has an available Mini PCIe slot to host the card (a common feature on better notebooks). The Killer Wireless-N 1202 is certainly inexpensive enough: I’ve seen it selling online for as little as $35 (Intel’s card is street-priced at about $30).

The key selling point of Killer NIC technology is its ability to identify the types of traffic traveling over your network and to assign higher priority to latency-sensitive traffic, such as online games, HD video, and audio.

Latency is a measure of time delay. When applications such as online games and streaming media encounter too much latency, you’ll end up with visible and/or audible glitches and hiccups. If you’re playing a first-person shooter with an online opponent, latency can render you a frustratingly easy target.

To evaluate each card’s ability to combat network latency, Qualcomm provided me with its Gaming Network Efficiency (GaNE) benchmark to measure ping (the time required for a packet to make a round trip on the network) and jitter (undesirable deviations in signal timing). Qualcomm offered to allow us to examine the program’s source code to ensure that there were no shenanigans.

GaNE measures real-time performance from two wireless clients at once, recording the results on a third computer that’s hardwired to the network. This way, both client adapters are subject to the same environmental conditions—an important variable when you’re benchmarking wireless performance. The tool measures latency between two networked PCs by sending a 100-byte packet on a round trip over the network every 50 milliseconds (100 bytes is the typical packet size on gaming networks, and 50ms is the typical interval between packets on the same). I used my longtime favorite 802.11n Wi-Fi router, a dual-band Asus RT-N66U, for these tests.

The GaNE benchmark, which measures latency and jitter, shows the Killer NIC to be the superior Wi-Fi adapter for latency-sensitive applications such as online games.

I set up the two wireless clients about 9 feet from the router in the same room, so no walls stood in between, and I connected them to the router’s 2.4GHz network. I then performed six runs of the GaNE benchmark. GaNE reported an average ping time for the Killer Wireless-N 1202 of about 1.5 milliseconds, and an average ping of nearly 4 milliseconds for the Intel card. What’s more, GaNE measured one-and-a-half times more jitter with Intel’s card than it did with Qualcomm’s. The Killer NIC delivered similar performance when I switched the clients over to the router’s 5GHz network—slightly less than 2 milliseconds—but Intel’s card registered a much higher average ping of nearly 8 milliseconds.

I also used the Asus RT-N66U to compare the adapters’ TCP-throughput performance, using JPERF (the Java front end to the TCP-throughput benchmark iPERF). The two adapters traded places on the 2.4GHz frequency band, but when the Killer Wireless-N 1202 won, it won by a significant margin. When the client was in the same room as the router, 9 feet away with no walls in between, it was 10.7 mbps faster than Intel’s component. And when the client was in my home office, 65 feet away and separated by three insulated interior walls, the Killer NIC was more than 25 mbps faster. At the two locations at which Intel’s adapter prevailed—in the kitchen (20 feet from the router) and in the home theater (35 feet from the router)—the margins were just 0.5 mbps and 4.0 mbps respectively.

Qualcomm's Killer Wireless-N 1202 and Intel's Advanced-N 6230 had comparable performance on the 2.4GHz band, but the Killer NIC was much faster when situated far from the router.

When I tested each adapter on the 5GHz network, Intel’s NIC performed much better—at close range, at least. In the bedroom test, the Centrino Advanced-N 6230 delivered TCP throughput of 196.0 mbps to the Killer’s 121.0 mbps. And when I moved the clients to the kitchen, Intel’s component was more than twice as fast as Qualcomm’s. But when I tested each client at longer distances, the tables turned, and the Killer NIC delivered dramatically higher TCP throughput than Intel’s card. In the home theater, the Killer delivered 81.1 mbps to the Centrino’s 30.1 mbps; and in the home office, Qualcomm’s card produced a rate of 63.8 mbps to Intel’s 34.9 mbps.

On the 5GHz band, Intel's adapter was much faster than the Killer NIC at close range. But the Killer card turned the tables at long range.

So Qualcomm’s Killer Wireless-N 1202 is a great Wi-Fi adapter. What happens if you’ve upgraded—or are planning to upgrade—to a router based on the new 802.11ac standard? Well, such routers are backward-compatible with 802.11n, so a Killer NIC will still work with one. But if that’s where you’re at, I think the better bet is to switch to an 802.11ac adapter. In fact, some notebook manufacturers—including Alienware—are already offering 802.11ac Wi-Fi adapters as standard equipment on higher-end laptop models (and tellingly, Alienware does not offer the Killer NIC—which is currently available only in 802.11n configurations—as an option on those models).

You should also remember your other option: a hardwired ethernet connection. If you don’t mind stringing cable, a hardwired connection will be faster than any wireless setup, and you won’t have to worry much about latency or jitter at all. But most people don’t want to hassle with cables these days, because wireless connections are so much more convenient.

If you’re buying a new gaming notebook and the seller offers the Killer NIC as a modestly priced upgrade (say, no more than $30), it’s definitely worth the money. The same goes if you’re upgrading a laptop with a Mini PCIe expansion slot and two internal antennas (Qualcomm's Killer Wireless-N1103 supports three antennas). But if you can get an 802.11ac adapter, that would be an even better investment. In fact, I’m surprised Qualcomm isn’t already offering a Killer NIC based on that spec.

A lapsed musician, Michael is passionate about home and personal audio. He uses his home as a real-world test lab for evaluating consumer electronics and home control technology.
More by Michael Brown


View the original article here

Thursday, 25 July 2013

Netgear 802.11ac A6200 WiFi Adapter

Pros Supports 802.11ac.

Cons Unimpressive throughput. Buggy software. Puzzling design. Bottom Line While Netgear has a decent 802.11ac router in its R6300, its 802.11ac adapter suffers from poor performance, buggy software, and a clunky design.

By Samara Lynn

802.11ac is a new wireless standard worth getting excited about, even though it has yet to be ratified. Netgear has a solid 11ac router on the market, the R6300 WiFi Router 802.11ac Dual Band Gigabit, and an 802.11ac wireless adapter to go with it: the 802.11ac A6200 WiFi Adapter. Unfortunately, the A6200 is less impressive than the router and that's testing it with the R6300—which should turn in its best test results. In fact, in 11ac mode the A6200 is among the slower-performing 11ac wireless adapters we've tested, and its performance in other modes is underwhelming, too. Add in some quirky software and this is an adapter that needed more time in the oven.

Compare Selected

Specs and Design
The A6200 supports up to 300 Mbps at 2.4 GHz and 867 Mbps at 5 GHz.  It can work on USB 1.1 or 2.0 ports, and it only works with Windows 8, 7, XP, and Vista—either 32 or 64 bit.

The adapter measures 3.75 by 1.23 by 0.56 inches (HWD). It can plug right into a computer's USB port or you can connect its accompanying USB base (which the adapter then connects to) into a USB port.  The adapter also has an antenna that you can push up or to the side, kind of like a stiff little arm that sticks out from the antenna—the antenna and the base are to give users adapter placement flexibility.

I have to state outright that I don't like the design. First of all, no matter which way I had the antenna arm oriented, or whether I had the adapter plugged in directly to the USB port or the base, made no difference in performance in my testing. Also the adapter and the way you move the antenna reminds me of those snake toys back in the 80's, remember? You could twist and bend the puzzle into shapes like a dog or diamond.  I think the design is too overcomplicated and the antenna arm seems like you could easily break it if you accidentally twisted it the wrong way. 

The adapter is dual-band but, honestly, the performance at either band and in any wireless mode is a big yawn. 

Setup
The A6200 ships with a resource CD. Pop in the CD and it auto-runs, opening up a menu of options. These include: Setup, Install Windows Standalone Driver, Documentation, Customer Support, and Online Registration.

I opted for Setup. I have to say, the Genie software that installed with the adapter's Windows drivers is a poorly designed eyesore and, worse, it's buggy. The interface froze on me once, and every time I opened it and clicked to scan for all wireless networks in range, the networks would show up and then a few seconds later, they would all disappear. This happened to me several times.

I don't even care for the way the installed software opens. After it installs, a Network Genie shortcut is placed on the desktop. I double-click it open and all I see is the icon appear minimized in the Windows System Tray at the bottom-right of my laptop's screen. So then I have to click on the icon minimized to open the program. Opening the software takes two steps therefore, instead of one.

If you do decide to go with the A6200, therefore, I recommend not using the CD's Setup option. Just install the Windows standalone drivers.

Performance
Yes, you will be able to surf the Web fine with the A6200. Yet, for any internal network multimedia streaming or large file handling, there may be some latency. The adapter produced unimpressive performance even with Netgeat's R6300 router.  At 15 feet from the R6300 in 802.11ac mode, throughput reached 74 Mbps. I've seen triple digit throughput in that mode from other pre-draft 802.11ac routers such as the Linksys Wireless Mini USB Adapter AC 580 Dual Band (AE6000) and the Asus USB-AC53 Dual-band Wireless-AC1200 Adapter.

The A6200's performance is more on par with another 802.11ac adapter that I found less-than-impressive, the Trendnet AC1200 Dual Band Wireless USB Adapter . The A6200 had a slighter edge at the 2.4GHz mode over the Trendnet: At 15 feet the A6200 clocked 64 Mbps versus 33 for the Trendnet. We rated the Trendnet adapter two out of five stars. Click on the image for the full comparison chart.Benchmark

Because of a performance edge over the Trendnet in the 2.4 GHz band, the A6200 earns 2.5 stars. I expect Netgear will offer another 802.11ac adapter that's quite a bit more robust when the 802.11ac standard is ratified. For now, it's just an adapter that I can't quite recommend, not only for performance but bcause of the buggy software and clunky design. The Editors' choice for 802.11ac wireless adapters remains Edimax's AC1200 Wireless Dual-Band USB Adapter.


View the original article here