Showing posts with label never. Show all posts
Showing posts with label never. Show all posts

Saturday, 21 September 2013

What We Can Never, Ever Know: Does Science Have Limits?

I got two books in the mail that, if they could have, would've poked, scratched and ripped each others' pages out. I don't know if Martin Gardner and Patricia Churchland ever met, but their books show that there are radically, even ferociously, different ways to think about science. Gardner died last year. He was a science writer whose monthly "Mathematical Games" column in Scientific American was wildly popular. Patricia Churchland is a philosopher who teaches at U.C. San Diego.

The issue between them is: How much can we know about the universe?

A chimpanzee. iStockphoto.com

"I am a mysterian," says Gardner, in his new (posthumously published) autobiography. Mysterians, he writes, believe that some things — how life began, the nature of time, what consciousness is, whether there is free will — are so inherently complex that they will forever elude human understanding. Not only does "no philosopher or scientist living today [have] the foggiest notion" of how mind or time or consciousness work, "we believe" he wrote, "it is the height of hubris" to suppose those things will ever be understood completely.

Forever Unintelligible

Gardner allows that humans have wonderful brains, that we can invent thinking machines, microscopes and any number of intelligence-enhancers, but he says there are still limits, hard limits.

Just as "there is no way to teach calculus to a chimp, or even make it understand the square root of 2," he writes, "surely there are truths as far beyond our grasp as our grasp is beyond that of a cow." He concedes that once upon a time humans were chimp-like and over time developed brains that cracked the "square root of 2" problem — but that doesn't faze him. There are properties of our universe so profoundly complex that no sentient mind, no matter how enhanced, will ever understand them fully.

iStockphoto.com A confused orangutan.

It's not clear from his book whether this is a scaling problem (that our brains are too small and the universe too, too big) or if the universe has been deeply designed to stay mysterious to its inhabitants. Either way, in his book he insists that some mysteries are permanent.

Gardner was a fine science writer, fearless, imaginative, daring. But he pushes his argument very far. Because some scientific questions are unanswerable, he says, maybe we shouldn't investigate them, that "[t]hese questions are so far above our natural human prowess that to fret about them seems as ridiculous as insisting that a dog understand general relativity."

Ignorance Is Just Ignorance

Patricia Churchland hates this notion. "Ignorance is just ignorance," she says. If you don't know something that doesn't mean you will never know it. In her new book, she writes, "There is something smugly arrogant about thinking, 'If I, with my great and wondrous brain, cannot imagine a solution to explain a phenomenon, then obviously the phenomenon cannot be explained at all. ... What I can and cannot imagine is a psychological fact about me. It is not a deep metaphysical fact about the nature of the universe.' "

For centuries, she says, authority figures have argued that we will never understand germs or earthquakes or atoms or volcanoes — that even to try was to trespass on divine territory. But we trespassed. We asked. We probed. And we learned. People who say we will never fathom the nature of consciousness are just doing what previous authorities did — they are choosing to hide from knowledge; they're cowards.

Yay, Brain

When a friend of hers, another philosophy professor, jumped out of his seat at a conference and yelled, "I hate the brain, I hate the brain!" because all this attention to brain science was taking attention away from philosophical pursuits, she smelled his fear. "Does he worry that neuro-knowledge is forbidden fruit, a Promethean fire, a Pandora's box, ... an evil genie released from a rightly sealed bottle?"

Patricia Churchland calls people like Martin Gardner "anti-enlightenment." She's proud of the human brain, its reasoning ability, its resourcefulness, and given enough time, she suspects, no question is unanswerable, there are no permanent mysteries. In the end (and the end is a long, long time away), we will know it all.

Asking, Asking, Asking

And, then, a third book fell into my lap, not from a scientist, but from a poet, Stanley Kunitz. His views on this subject, casually mentioned at the end of a chapter, are my own. He wrote that he finds his life, his being here, deeply mystifying. He loses friends to diseases and doesn't know why. He loves deeply, but doesn't know how. "Can there be any possibility of completely understanding who we are and why we're here and where we're going? These are questions that can never be answered completely," Kunitz says, contradicting Patricia. But then, contradicting Martin, he takes the crucial next step, "But you have to keep on asking ..."

To me, that's the beauty of science: to know that you will never know everything, but you never stop wanting to, that when you learn something, for a second you feel crazy smart, and then stupid all over again as new questions come tumbling in. It's an urge that never dies, a game that never ends. Science is a rough trade, played, I hope, forever — and, sorry Patricia, sorry Martin, that's how I think of it, not limited, not unlimited, just an itch that always needs scratching.

———————————————————————————————————————-

Patricia Churchland's new book is called Touching a Nerve: The Self As Brain. Martin Gardner's upcoming autobiography, to be released next month is Undiluted Hocus-Pocus, The Autobiography of Martin Gardner. I found Stanley Kunitz's thoughts in Wild Braid: A Poet Reflects on a Century in the Garden.


View the original article here

Saturday, 24 August 2013

The comeback kid: How Yahoo, a site your friends never visit, dominates the Internet

When comScore reported on Thursday that Yahoo was the No. 1 most-visited website in the country—overtaking Google for the first time in two years—I admit I was surprised.

It wasn’t the Tumblr Effect. comScore counted Tumblr traffic separately—the microblogging site hovered at No. 28 in July. So if none of your friends use Yahoo, who does? A comScore spokesperson told TechHive the jump wasn’t attributable to any particular reason—rather, many of Yahoo’s sites, or channels, saw traffic increases.

I’m willing to bet Yahoo Mail saw a significant jump in July—that’s when Yahoo announced its plans to recycle inactive email accounts. Users who probably hadn’t visited Yahoo in months, even years, were encouraged to revive their accounts or reserve new screennames. No figures are available following that media blitz, but it’s a sure bet that users flocked to Yahoo to reserve names that had to sound better than the random words paired with a series of numbers that characterized many Yahoo accounts in the early aughts (“softballchick345678,” anyone?).

Yahoo WishlistYahoo Mail's campaign likely boosted traffic in July.

But aside from email users, who are all these Web surfers visiting Yahoo on their desktops? People obviously aren’t using Yahoo as their main search engine, which is how Google gains a large share of traffic. For instance, searches typed into Chrome’s navigation bar that turn up Google search results count as hits for Google, the comScore rep said. Yahoo doesn’t have that perk. The site ranked third behind Google and Microsoft in July with a paltry 11 percent of search engine traffic.

Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer has coordinated a killer public relations campaign for the company, which went from fuddy-duddy search engine to thriving media brand in a year. From the telecommuting policy she controversially ended to the 17-year-old entrepreneur she bought out for $30 million, Mayer knows how to make headlines. But that can’t be what’s driving Yahoo traffic, can it?

marissa mayerYahoo CEO Marissa Mayer

That leaves older Internet users, many of whom set Yahoo as their home page before Google was a twinkle in the eyes of Larry Page and Sergey Brin. It’s worth noting that comScore doesn’t include mobile traffic in its numbers. Can a website really win the Internet without mobile traffic to back it up? Probably not.

Until Yahoo can sustain its Internet domination, we’ll call July’s numbers a one-off. But watch your back, Google. Yahoo is clearly circling the nest. The company's second-quarter profits were up 46 percent and Yahoo has launched almost a dozen new products since Mayer took the helm. A front page redesign, Flickr relaunch, new mobile apps, and other Mayer-led initiatives prove that Yahoo is in it to win it. The company's next project: A new logo to reflect the new Yahoo.

Caitlin writes about all things social media. She is addicted to the 24-hour news cycle and Mission burritos.
More by Caitlin McGarry


View the original article here

The comeback kid: How Yahoo, a site your friends never visit, dominates the Internet

When comScore reported on Thursday that Yahoo was the No. 1 most-visited website in the country—overtaking Google for the first time in two years—I admit I was surprised.

It wasn’t the Tumblr Effect. comScore counted Tumblr traffic separately—the microblogging site hovered at No. 28 in July. So if none of your friends use Yahoo, who does? A comScore spokesperson told TechHive the jump wasn’t attributable to any particular reason—rather, many of Yahoo’s sites, or channels, saw traffic increases.

I’m willing to bet Yahoo Mail saw a significant jump in July—that’s when Yahoo announced its plans to recycle inactive email accounts. Users who probably hadn’t visited Yahoo in months, even years, were encouraged to revive their accounts or reserve new screennames. No figures are available following that media blitz, but it’s a sure bet that users flocked to Yahoo to reserve names that had to sound better than the random words paired with a series of numbers that characterized many Yahoo accounts in the early aughts (“softballchick345678,” anyone?).

Yahoo WishlistYahoo Mail's campaign likely boosted traffic in July.

But aside from email users, who are all these Web surfers visiting Yahoo on their desktops? People obviously aren’t using Yahoo as their main search engine, which is how Google gains a large share of traffic. For instance, searches typed into Chrome’s navigation bar that turn up Google search results count as hits for Google, the comScore rep said. Yahoo doesn’t have that perk. The site ranked third behind Google and Microsoft in July with a paltry 11 percent of search engine traffic.

Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer has coordinated a killer public relations campaign for the company, which went from fuddy-duddy search engine to thriving media brand in a year. From the telecommuting policy she controversially ended to the 17-year-old entrepreneur she bought out for $30 million, Mayer knows how to make headlines. But that can’t be what’s driving Yahoo traffic, can it?

marissa mayerYahoo CEO Marissa Mayer

That leaves older Internet users, many of whom set Yahoo as their home page before Google was a twinkle in the eyes of Larry Page and Sergey Brin. It’s worth noting that comScore doesn’t include mobile traffic in its numbers. Can a website really win the Internet without mobile traffic to back it up? Probably not.

Until Yahoo can sustain its Internet domination, we’ll call July’s numbers a one-off. But watch your back, Google. Yahoo is clearly circling the nest. The company's second-quarter profits were up 46 percent and Yahoo has launched almost a dozen new products since Mayer took the helm. A front page redesign, Flickr relaunch, new mobile apps, and other Mayer-led initiatives prove that Yahoo is in it to win it. The company's next project: A new logo to reflect the new Yahoo.

Caitlin writes about all things social media. She is addicted to the 24-hour news cycle and Mission burritos.
More by Caitlin McGarry


View the original article here

Tuesday, 20 August 2013

NSA-dodging mail service explains why email can never truly be private and secure

Earlier this month, Lavabit and Silent Circle—two privacy-minded email providers—decided to shut up shop rather than give the U.S. government the chance to access to their customer data. Shortly thereafter, Lavabit owner Ladar Levison told Forbes, "If you knew what I knew about email, you might not use it."

This weekend, Silent Circle's Louis Kowolowski dropped the cryptic comments and explained a major, inherent vulnerability with email: metadata.

While encryption technologies like PGP and SMIME can be used to obscure the actual contents of a message, assuming you use a desktop program that supports encryption software, current email protocols don't allow you to secure the "header" metadata details that are used to shuffle email from point to point. The sender, recipient, subject, date and time, and even server path information is all sent along in clear text.

That's enough to be a liability to people who truly need privacy, according to Kowolowski.

If your goal is to not have metadata leakage in your otherwise secure communications, you may wish to avoid email altogether. Email leaks the information about who is communicating, and how often. This information may be just as damaging as the content of the email.

Snowden's leaks have shown that the U.S. government is aware of the power of metadata. The NSA collects Verizon's phone records to examine metadata and analyze call patterns, and the government does not need individual warrants to do so, as courts have classified metadata as "transactional data" rather than actual communications. Again, here's Kowolowski:

With the tapping of backbone internet providers, interested parties can now see all traffic on the internet. The days where it was possible for two people to have a truly private conversation over email, if they ever existed, are long over.

Since text, video, and messaging communications don't suffer from the same header needs as email, they're able to be secured from end-to-end, with all encryption and decryption handled on the client machines—and indeed, Silent Circle still offers "Silent Phone," "Silent Eyes," and "Silent Text" services that do just that. Check out our guiding to protecting your PC from Prism surveillance for more privacy-minded tips and tricks, or if metadata security means less than the message itself, read PCWorld's guide to securing your email.

Brad Chacos spends the days jamming to Spotify, digging through desktop PCs and covering everything from BYOD tablets to DIY tesla coils.
More by Brad Chacos


View the original article here