Showing posts with label customers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label customers. Show all posts

Thursday, 29 August 2013

IBM starts restricting hardware patches to paying customers

Following through on a policy change announced in 2012, IBM has started restricting availability of hardware patches to paying customers, spurring at least one advocacy group to accuse the company of anticompetitive practices.

IBM "is getting to the spot where the customer has no choice but to buy an IBM maintenance agreement, or lose access to patches and changes," said Gay Gordon-Byrne, executive director of the DRTR (Digital Right to Repair), a coalition for championing the rights of digital equipment owners.

[ For a quick, smart take on the news you'll be talking about, check out InfoWorld TechBrief -- subscribe today. ]

Such a practice could dampen the market for support service of IBM equipment from non-IBM contractors, and could diminish the resale value of IBM equipment, DRTR charged.

On Aug. 11, IBM began requiring visitors of the IBM Fix Central website to provide a serial number in order to download a patch or update. According to DRTR, IBM uses the serial number to check to see if the machine being repaired was under a current IBM maintenance contract, or under an IBM hardware warranty.

"IBM will take the serial number, validate it against its maintenance contract database, and allow [user ] to proceed or not," Gordon-Byrne explained.

Traditionally, IBM has freely provided machine code patches and updates as a matter of quality control, Gordon-Byrne said. The company left it to the owner to decide how to maintain the equipment, either through the help of IBM, a third-party service-provider, or by itself.

This benevolent practice is starting to change, according to DRTR.

In April 2012, IBM started requiring customers to sign a license in order to access machine code updates. Then, in October of that year, the company announced that machine code updates would only be available for those customers with IBM equipment that was either under warranty or covered by an IBM maintenance agreement.

"Fix Central downloads are available only for IBM clients with hardware or software under warranty, maintenance contracts, or subscription and support," stated the Fix Central site documentation.

Nor would IBM offer the fixes on a time-and-material contract, in which customers can go through a special bid process to buy annual access to machine code.

The company didn't immediately start enforcing this entitlement comparison policy however -- until earlier this month. "Until August, it didn't appear that IBM had the capability," Gordon-Byrne said. "We were wondering when they were going to do that step."

The policy seems to apply to all IBM mainframes, servers and storage systems, with IBM X system servers being one known exception. Customer complaints forced IBM to halt the practice for X servers, according to Gordon-Byrne.

This practice is problematic to IBM customers for a number of reasons, DRTR asserted.

Such a practice limits the resale of hardware, because any prospective owner of used equipment would have to purchase a support contract from IBM if it wanted its newly acquired machine updated.

And this could be expensive. IBM also announced last year it would start charging a "re-establishment fee" for equipment owners wishing to sign a new maintenance contract for equipment with lapsed IBM support coverage. The fee could be as high as 150 percent of the yearly maintenance fee itself, according to DRTR.

IBM could also use the maintenance contracts as a way to generate more sales.


View the original article here

IBM starts restricting hardware patches to paying customers

Following through on a policy change announced in 2012, IBM has started restricting availability of hardware patches to paying customers, spurring at least one advocacy group to accuse the company of anticompetitive practices.

IBM “is getting to the spot where the customer has no choice but to buy an IBM maintenance agreement or lose access to patches and changes,” said Gay Gordon-Byrne, executive director of the Digital Right to Repair (DRTR), a coalition for championing the rights of digital equipment owners.

Such a practice could dampen the market for support service of IBM equipment from non-IBM contractors, and could diminish the resale value of IBM equipment, DRTR charged.

On Aug. 11, IBM began requiring visitors of the IBM Fix Central website to provide a serial number in order to download a patch or update. According to DRTR, IBM uses the serial number to check to see if the machine being repaired was under a current IBM maintenance contract, or under an IBM hardware warranty.

“IBM will take the serial number, validate it against its maintenance contract database, and allow [user ] to proceed or not,” Gordon-Byrne explained.

Traditionally, IBM has freely provided machine code patches and updates as a matter of quality control, Gordon-Byrne said. The company left it to the owner to decide how to maintain the equipment, either through the help of IBM, a third-party service-provider, or by itself.

This benevolent practice is starting to change, according to DRTR.

In April 2012, IBM started requiring customers to sign a license in order to access machine code updates. Then, in October of that year, the company announced that machine code updates would only be available for those customers with IBM equipment that was either under warranty or covered by an IBM maintenance agreement.

“Fix Central downloads are available only for IBM clients with hardware or software under warranty, maintenance contracts, or subscription and support,” stated the Fix Central site documentation.

Nor would IBM offer the fixes on a time-and-material contract, in which customers can go through a special bid process to buy annual access to machine code.

The company didn’t immediately start enforcing this entitlement comparison policy however—until earlier this month. “Until August, it didn’t appear that IBM had the capability,” Gordon-Byrne said. “We were wondering when they were going to do that step.”

The policy seems to apply to all IBM mainframes, servers, and storage systems, with IBM X system servers being one known exception. Customer complaints forced IBM to halt the practice for X servers, according to Gordon-Byrne.

This practice is problematic to IBM customers for a number of reasons, DRTR asserted.

Such a practice limits the resale of hardware, because any prospective owner of used equipment would have to purchase a support contract from IBM if it wanted its newly acquired machine updated.

And this could be expensive. IBM also announced last year it would start charging a “re-establishment fee” for equipment owners wishing to sign a new maintenance contract for equipment with lapsed IBM support coverage. The fee could be as high as 150 percent of the yearly maintenance fee itself, according to DRTR.

IBM could also use the maintenance contracts as a way to generate more sales.

“If IBM decides it wants to jack the maintenance price in order to make a new machine sale, they can do it because there is no competition,” Gordon-Byrne said.

IBM is not the first major hardware firm to use this tactic to generate more after-market sales, according to Gordon-Byrne. Oracle adopted a similar practice for its servers after it acquired Sun Microsystems, and its considerable line of hardware, in 2010.

The Service Industry Association—which focuses on helping the computer, medical and business products service industries— created DRTR in January 2013 to fight against encroaching after-market control of hardware manufacturers. The SIA itself protested Oracle’s move away from free patches as well.

DRTR is actively tracking a number of similar cases involving after-market control of hardware, such as an Avaya antitrust trial due to start Sept. 9 in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey.

IBM declined to comment for this story.

Joab Jackson covers enterprise software and general technology breaking news for the IDG News Service.
More by Joab Jackson


View the original article here

Friday, 16 August 2013

Microsoft to sell struggling Surface tablets to business customers outside the U.S.

Microsoft will start selling its struggling Surface devices to business customers abroad via channel partners on Thursday.

The move builds on a similar effort Microsoft launched in July to tap distributors and resellers to push Surface tablets to businesses in the U.S.

The channel program goes into effect in Canada and 16 European countries, including France, Germany, Italy, Sweden, and the U.K.

Until now, Microsoft only sold Surfaces in a limited way directly to business customers in these countries, as it had done in the U.S. prior to July.

Microsoft Surface in Palo AltoMartyn WilliamsThe computer not enough people want.

The initial set of international distributors and resellers have been hand-picked by Microsoft using criteria like their geographic reach, experience selling tablets to businesses and the complementary services they’re able to offer customers.

“Like we did in the U.S. last month, we’re taking a measured approach at first, and plan to expand later,” said Cyril Belikoff, Microsoft’s Surface marketing director.

These channel partners will target private-sector companies, government customers and schools and universities. They will honor Microsoft warranties and provide services like asset tagging, custom imaging, on-site service, device recycling and data protection.

The other countries included in the channel program are Spain, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, Ireland, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal and Switzerland.

Microsoft’s next goal is to extend the channel program to the other 10 countries where the Surface is available via its retail channel program.

The Surface, a Microsoft-branded tablet, hasn’t sold well since its launch 10 months ago. It was also controversial from the start because it competes against other Windows RT and Windows 8 tablets made by Microsoft’s hardware partners.

It comes in two main editions: the Surface Pro, which runs Windows 8 for x86 chips, and the Surface RT, which runs Windows RT, the Windows 8 version for devices that use ARM chips. Microsoft executives have said the company plans to make more products like the Surface, in which it’s in charge of both the OS and the hardware, in a nod to the success Apple has had with that model.

Microsoft Surface in Palo AltoMartyn WilliamsMicrosoft hopes the $350 Surface RT or $800 Pro will be suitable for the suits.

In the first quarter, Microsoft shipped 900,000 Surface tablets, a 1.8 percent market share, according to IDC. Leading the pack was Apple with 19.5 million iPad shipments and a market share of almost 40 percent, followed by Samsung with 18 percent share, Asus (5.5 percent) and Amazon.com (3.7 percent).

IDC noted in that report that Windows 8 and Windows RT tablets from other hardware manufacturers had struggled to gain traction as well—1.8 million Windows RT and Windows 8 tablets shipped in the first quarter.

In the second calendar quarter, 1.8 million tablets shipped worldwide ran Windows 8, good for 4 percent share, while 200,000 Windows RT tablets shipped, a 0.5 percent share, according to IDC. That compares with market share of 63 percent and 33 percent respectively for Android and iOS. Surface shipments, however, plummeted to around 300,000, IDC told CiteWorld.

In its fourth fiscal quarter, ended June 30, Microsoft took a $900 million charge for Surface RT inventory adjustments, and later said in a regulatory filing that Surface sales in the quarter had generated $853 million in revenue.

Since the Surface launch, Microsoft has cut the price of the Surface Pro and the Surface RT and run promotions to try and spur sales.

Surface RT in particular has been a tough sell to businesses because Windows RT devices can’t run existing Windows 7 applications, only new applications built for the new OS and available in the Windows Store. Moreover, Windows RT ships with a version of Office, but it’s not licensed for commercial use.

In addition, Windows RT lacks many IT management features and doesn’t support the Outlook email client, but Microsoft is addressing those two issues in the 8.1 update of the OS, which is now in previews and slated for general availability in mid-October.

The Surface RT now starts at $349.

The Surface Pro is more powerful and can run legacy Windows applications, but it starts at $799 and reviewers have faulted its limited battery life. It started shipping in February.

Juan Carlos Perez covers e-commerce, Google, web-application development, and cloud applications for the IDG News Service.
More by Juan Carlos Perez


View the original article here